Lionel Messi’s 2016 “#backedbyMessi” list was an intriguing mix of high hopes and uneven outcomes: a clear success in Kasper Dolberg, a few steady professionals, and several careers that stalled amid loans and transfers. The cohort underlines football’s scouting uncertainty — Messi spotted talent, but development paths and circumstances determined who truly rose.
Messi's 2016 "backedbyMessi" list: promise, picks and context
Lionel Messi’s 2016 selection — part of the adidas-backed initiative — aimed to spotlight ten young players he believed could grow into top-level stars. The gesture carried weight because the name of the MLS star amplifies attention and expectation. Yet talent ID is only the first chapter; coaching, club stability, injuries and mindset shape the rest.
Where the ten picks are now — quick verdicts
Kasper Dolberg — the clearest success
Dolberg emerged as the cohort’s standout. After a breakout at Ajax he moved to Nice, earned club Player of the Season plaudits, and later returned to Ajax. Regular Danish international caps and a steady goal return show a player who converted early promise into a sustained top‑level career.
Davide Calabria — dependable professional
Calabria’s path has been the most traditionally successful: he established himself at AC Milan, became captain and racked up over 270 appearances before leaving after a long spell. His trajectory illustrates how steady development at one club can deliver consistent value, even if it lacks flash.
Jean‑Kévin Augustin — the unfulfilled trajectory
Augustin’s early pace through PSG into RB Leipzig showed striker potential, but repeated loans (Monaco, Leeds) and limited minutes stalled momentum. A move to Nantes and spells out of the spotlight underline how confidence and consistent playing time are vital for young forwards.
Patrick Roberts — talent dimmed by instability
Roberts flashed at Celtic on loan from Manchester City, winning awards and a title. But subsequent moves — Girona, Norwich, multiple Championship loans — prevented the sustained platform he needed. His career speaks to how loan overload can blunt a winger’s development.
Gabriel Boschilia — early promise, continental reset
Boschilia impressed at Monaco in 2016/17 but then drifted through loans in Belgium and France before returning to Brazil, where he rebuilt his career. His story is familiar: technical quality intact, but the continental move didn’t translate into a long-term European breakthrough.
Alex Muyl — MLS mainstay
Muyl is a reminder that success can be regional. From the New York Red Bulls to Nashville SC, he accumulated large appearance numbers and became a reliable MLS professional. That steady domestic career is a different but valid interpretation of success.
Chanathip Songkrasin — regional star and commercial success
The “Thai Messi” became a proven performer in the J.League with Consadole Sapporo and Kawasaki Frontale, breaking domestic transfer records in Japan. Chanathip’s rise shows that global talent paths aren’t always to Europe; excelling in Asia can deliver elite status and national-team impact.
Nadezhda Karpova — profile, movement and voice
Karpova was the lone female pick and had spells across Spain with Valencia, Sevilla and Espanyol. Her club movements and public stance on political issues brought visibility beyond goals and assists, highlighting how women’s careers can intersect with off‑field influence.
Kekutah Manneh — flashes, then fragmentation
Manneh’s early Whitecaps output earned interest, but frequent moves and short stints in MLS and other North American clubs left him without long-term stability. His career illustrates how early pace and productivity still require the right environment to flourish.
Nathan — loan system’s casualties and reinvention
A Chelsea-owned youngster with productive loans at Vitesse, Nathan ultimately found permanence back in Brazil at Atlético Mineiro. Over 100 appearances there showed reinvention away from Europe’s spotlight, a common rescue route for talented Brazilians who don’t crack the Chelsea pathway.
Analysis: what the list really tells us
Messi’s picks highlighted potential across positions and continents, but the mixed outcomes expose two truths. First, a single endorsement can open doors but not guarantee development. Second, environment matters: stable coaching, playing time and club faith are determinative.
The cohort also showcases different valid measures of success. Dolberg and Calabria followed traditional European success routes; Chanathip and Muyl built regional profiles that are commercially and competitively significant; others remind us how fragile early momentum can be.
What to watch next
For players still active or recently free agents, the next move is critical. A settled club with a clear role could reignite stalled careers; conversely, further short‑term deals risk permanent decline. For scouts and clubs, this group is a case study: identifying potential is only half the job — managing it is where elite clubs separate themselves.
Conclusion
Messi’s 2016 selections were never guarantees — they were bets on talent. Evaluating the group a decade on shows the limits of celebrity endorsements and the power of context.
Beyond the Messi Rivalry: LAFC reveals the strategic move behind Griezmann's signing
Talent identification remains an art; development is the science that decides the final grade.
Givemesport
